你如何强制在点上的节点上排名？

Question

我有一些graphviz点格式的相对简单(自动生成)的图形.这些显示了通过状态机的路径,但是当我希望图形处于状态顺序时,dot有一个稍微混乱的习惯,即决定两个节点必须在同一个等级上.我已经尝试了很多的设置(包括:n和:s和weight下面列出的),但我无法说服点,放置第三个国家以上的第四个国家.

我有很多图表存在这个问题:点似乎有一些东西可以决定如果两个节点在同一个等级上会更好,并且没有什么可以覆盖它.我甚至有代码指定一个节点应该是a rank=sink,但是dot决定将另一个节点放在它下面.

有没有办法建议点,节点的顺序比任何其他约束更重要？

用于生成图形的代码如下所示:

digraph {
    ERROR [label="Error"];
    FirstSTATE [label="Initial State" URL="\ref FirstSTATE"];
    FirstSTATE -> SecondSTATE;
    SecondSTATE [label="Second State" URL="\ref SecondSTATE"];
    SecondSTATE -> ThirdSTATE;
    ThirdSTATE [label="Third State" URL="\ref ThirdSTATE"];
    FourthSTATE [label="Fouth State?" shape="diamond"];
    ThirdSTATE:s -> FourthSTATE:n [weight=50];
    FourthSTATE -> FifthSTATE [label="Yes" ];
    FourthSTATE -> ThirdSTATE [label="No"];
    FifthSTATE [label="Fifth State" URL="\ref FifthSTATE"];
    SixthSTATE [label="Sixth State?" shape="diamond"];
    SixthSTATE -> ERROR [label="Yes" ];
    SixthSTATE -> SeventhSTATE [label="No"];
    FifthSTATE -> SixthSTATE;
    SeventhSTATE [label="Seventh State" URL="\ref SeventhSTATE"];
    SeventhSTATE -> EighthSTATE;
    EighthSTATE [label="Eighth State" URL="\ref EighthSTATE"];
    NinthSTATE [label="Ninth State?" shape="diamond"];
    NinthSTATE -> TenthSTATE [label="Yes" ];
    NinthSTATE -> EighthSTATE [label="No"];
    EighthSTATE -> NinthSTATE;
    TenthSTATE [label="Tenth State" URL="\ref TenthSTATE"];
    EleventhSTATE [label="Eleventh State?" shape="diamond"];
    EleventhSTATE -> ERROR [label="Yes" ];
    EleventhSTATE -> TwelfthSTATE [label="No" ];
    TenthSTATE -> EleventhSTATE;
    TwelfthSTATE [label="Twelfth State" URL="\ref TwelfthSTATE"];
}

该图表目前看起来像这样:

Answer 1

使用"constraint = false".

http://www.graphviz.org/doc/info/attrs.html#d:constraint

在你的图表中:

FourthSTATE -> ThirdSTATE [label="No" constraint=false] ;

你会得到:

digraph {
    ERROR [label="Error"];
    FirstSTATE [label="Initial State" URL="\ref FirstSTATE"];
    FirstSTATE -> SecondSTATE;
    SecondSTATE [label="Second State" URL="\ref SecondSTATE"];
    SecondSTATE -> ThirdSTATE;
    ThirdSTATE [label="Third State" URL="\ref ThirdSTATE"];
    FourthSTATE [label="Fouth State?" shape="diamond"];
    ThirdSTATE -> FourthSTATE;
    FourthSTATE -> FifthSTATE [label="Yes" ];
    FourthSTATE -> ThirdSTATE [label="No" constraint=false] ;
    FifthSTATE [label="Fifth State" URL="\ref FifthSTATE"];
    SixthSTATE [label="Sixth State?" shape="diamond"];
    SixthSTATE -> ERROR [label="Yes" ];
    SixthSTATE -> SeventhSTATE [label="No"];
    FifthSTATE -> SixthSTATE;
    SeventhSTATE [label="Seventh State" URL="\ref SeventhSTATE"];
    SeventhSTATE -> EighthSTATE;
    EighthSTATE [label="Eighth State" URL="\ref EighthSTATE"];
    NinthSTATE [label="Ninth State?" shape="diamond"];
    NinthSTATE -> TenthSTATE [label="Yes" ];
    NinthSTATE -> EighthSTATE [label="No"];
    EighthSTATE -> NinthSTATE;
    TenthSTATE [label="Tenth State" URL="\ref TenthSTATE"];
    EleventhSTATE [label="Eleventh State?" shape="diamond"];
    EleventhSTATE -> ERROR [label="Yes" ];
    EleventhSTATE -> TwelfthSTATE [label="No" ];
    TenthSTATE -> EleventhSTATE;
    TwelfthSTATE [label="Twelfth State" URL="\ref TwelfthSTATE"];
}