Node.js中的$ 2y bcrypt哈希值

Question

我正在处理带有$2y哈希的旧数据库.我已经挖了一下这个,也偶然发现堆栈溢出$2a和之间的区别$2y.

我查看了bcrypt似乎生成并仅比较$2a哈希的节点模块.

• https://github.com/ncb000gt/node.bcrypt.js/issues/175
• https://github.com/ncb000gt/node.bcrypt.js/issues/349
• https://github.com/ncb000gt/node.bcrypt.js/issues/213

我找到了一个生成$2y哈希的网站,所以我可以测试它们bcrypt.

• http://aspirine.org/htpasswd_en.html

这是一个$2y字符串哈希的例子helloworld.

helloworld:$2y$10$tRM7x9gGKhcAmpeqKEdhj.qRWCr4qoV1FU9se0Crx2hkMVNL2ktEW

似乎模块无法验证$2y哈希值.

这是我的考试.

var Promise = require('bluebird')
var bcrypt = require('bcrypt')

var string = 'helloworld'

Promise.promisifyAll(bcrypt)

// bcrypt.genSalt(10, function(err, salt) {
//   bcrypt.hash(string, salt, function(err, hash) {
//     console.log(hash)
//   })
// })

var hashesGeneratedUsingBcryptModule = [
  '$2a$10$6ppmIdlNEPwxWJskPaQ7l.d2fblh.GO6JomzrcpiD/hxGPOXA3Bsq',
  '$2a$10$YmpoYCDHzdAPMbd9B8l48.hkSnylnAPbOym367FKIEPa0ixY.o4b.',
  '$2a$10$Xfy3OPurrZEmbmmO0x1wGuFMdRTlmOgEMS0geg4wTj1vKcvXXjk06',
  '$2a$10$mYgwmdPZjiEncp7Yh5UB1uyPkoyavxrYcOIzzY4mzSniGpI9RbhL.',
  '$2a$10$dkBVTe2A2DAn24PUq1GZYe7AqL8WQqwOi8ZWBJAauOg60sk44DkOC'
]

var hashesGeneratedUsingAspirineDotOrg = [
  '$2y$10$MKgpAXLJkwx5tpijWX99Qek2gf/irwvp5iSfxuFoDswIjMIbj2.Ma',
  '$2y$10$tRM7x9gGKhcAmpeqKEdhj.qRWCr4qoV1FU9se0Crx2hkMVNL2ktEW'
]

var hashesGeneratedUsingAspirineDotOrgSwippedYForA = [
  '$2a$10$MKgpAXLJkwx5tpijWX99Qek2gf/irwvp5iSfxuFoDswIjMIbj2.Ma',
  '$2a$10$tRM7x9gGKhcAmpeqKEdhj.qRWCr4qoV1FU9se0Crx2hkMVNL2ktEW'
]

hashesGeneratedUsingBcryptModule = hashesGeneratedUsingBcryptModule.map(hash => bcrypt.compareAsync(string, hash))
hashesGeneratedUsingAspirineDotOrg = hashesGeneratedUsingAspirineDotOrg.map(hash => bcrypt.compareAsync(string, hash))
hashesGeneratedUsingAspirineDotOrgSwippedYForA = hashesGeneratedUsingAspirineDotOrgSwippedYForA.map(hash => bcrypt.compareAsync(string, hash))

Promise.all(hashesGeneratedUsingBcryptModule)
.tap(() => console.log('hashesGeneratedUsingBcryptModule'))
.then(console.log)

Promise.all(hashesGeneratedUsingAspirineDotOrg)
.tap(() => console.log('hashesGeneratedUsingAspirineDotOrg'))
.then(console.log)

Promise.all(hashesGeneratedUsingAspirineDotOrgSwippedYForA)
.tap(() => console.log('hashesGeneratedUsingAspirineDotOrgSwippedYForA'))
.then(console.log)

结果如下:

// hashesGeneratedUsingAspirineDotOrg
// [ false, false ]
// hashesGeneratedUsingBcryptModule
// [ true, true, true, true, true ]
// hashesGeneratedUsingAspirineDotOrgSwippedYForA
// [ false, false ]

我对如何比较$2y节点中的哈希感到难过.

还有另一个Stack Overflow问题/答案,说你可以改变$2y,$2a但对我来说仍然失败.

更新!

我错误地使用了生成器,因为它是一个.htpasswd密码生成器,你必须以这种格式输入用户名和密码.

reggi helloworld

输出对应于此:

reggi:$2y$10$iuC7GYH/h1Gl1aDmcpLFpeJXN9OZXZUYnaqD2NnGLQiVGQYBDtbtO

在我放入之前

helloword

我假设哈希是一个空字符串.

随着这些变化改变y为一个a工作bcrypt.而twin-bcrypt只是工作.

Answer 1

• 使用时bcrypt更改y为a.
• 使用twin-bcrypt哈希时才有效.

使用http://aspirine.org/htpasswd_en.html时,请确保提供用户名和密码.

reggi helloworld

然后:

reggi:$2y$10$Am0Nf/B6.S/Wkpr6IVdIZeuHWNa/fqoLyTNmlyrSg22AjRf2vS.T.

这是两个bcrypt和的一个工作示例twin-bcrypt.

var twinBcrypt = require('twin-bcrypt')
var bcrypt = require('bcrypt')

var string = 'helloworld'

var bcryptAttempt = bcrypt.compareSync(string, "$2y$10$Am0Nf/B6.S/Wkpr6IVdIZeuHWNa/fqoLyTNmlyrSg22AjRf2vS.T.".replace(/^\$2y/, "$2a"))
console.log(bcryptAttempt)

var twinBcryptAttempt = twinBcrypt.compareSync(string, "$2y$10$Am0Nf/B6.S/Wkpr6IVdIZeuHWNa/fqoLyTNmlyrSg22AjRf2vS.T.")
console.log(twinBcryptAttempt)

输出:

true
true