Doctrine加入两个具有单表继承的模型,第二个连接减慢速度

Jes*_*ica 9 php mysql single-table-inheritance symfony doctrine-orm

我有3个模型使用单表继承.它们适用于可在我们网站上购买的三种不同类型的商品.这些项目被分类,因此Category模型具有用于映射这三种类型中的每一种的属性.

当使用简单的选择来获取所有类别,然后在类别中显示它们的名称和每种类型的项目的数量时,Doctrine总共执行369个查询,总共549毫秒.(一个用于类别列表,然后一个用于类别中的每个类型.)

所以我开始在查询中添加联接以消除所有额外的查询.它适用于第一个项目类型,主查询运行在101.80毫秒.(根据Symfony Profiler工具栏)

$this->_em->createQueryBuilder()
        ->select([$alias, 'courses'])
        ->from($this->_entityName, $alias)
        ->leftJoin("{$alias}.courses", 'courses');
Run Code Online (Sandbox Code Playgroud)

只要我添加第二个连接,查询就会减慢到24050.14毫秒

$qb = $this->_em->createQueryBuilder()
        ->select([$alias, 'courses', 'bundles'])
        ->from($this->_entityName, $alias)
        ->leftJoin("{$alias}.courses", 'courses')
        ->leftJoin("{$alias}.bundles", 'bundles');
Run Code Online (Sandbox Code Playgroud)

我还没有尝试过第三次加入,担心它会让服务器崩溃.

真正奇怪的是,如果我使用Doctrine查询记录并获得确切的查询,并在我的数据库上手动运行它,它只运行0.2秒.

该表在所有FK列和鉴别器列上都有索引.

任何建议将不胜感激.谢谢!

编辑:4/3

我必须让分支回到其他问题的工作点才能回到这个问题.

SQL小提琴与架构(减去其他未在这种情况下加载的表的FK):http://sqlfiddle.com/#!28/85051

所以,我有没有连接的页面,并且它在820.38毫秒内进行了382次查询以进行延迟加载.当我手动加入,而不是依赖延迟加载,它以130为21159(这是唯一加盟模式2,所以它仍然懒加载第三)

$qb = $this->_em->createQueryBuilder()
        ->select([$alias, 'courses', 'bundles'])
        ->from($this->_entityName, $alias)
        ->leftJoin("{$alias}.courses", 'courses')
        ->leftJoin("{$alias}.bundles", 'bundles');
Run Code Online (Sandbox Code Playgroud)

这是来自Symfony工具栏的查询(20241.26 ms)

    SELECT 
  i0_.description AS description0, 
  i0_.id AS id1, 
  i0_.name AS name2, 
  i0_.created_at AS created_at3, 
  i0_.updated_at AS updated_at4, 
  i0_.display_order AS display_order5, 
  i1_.atccode AS atccode6, 
  i1_.version AS version7, 
  i1_.description AS description8, 
  i1_.online_price AS online_price9, 
  i1_.mail_price AS mail_price10, 
  i1_.is_featured AS is_featured11, 
  i1_.code AS code12, 
  i1_.hours AS hours13, 
  i1_.summary AS summary14, 
  i1_.seo_keywords AS seo_keywords15, 
  i1_.seo_description AS seo_description16, 
  i1_.asha_code AS asha_code17, 
  i1_.preview_name AS preview_name18, 
  i1_.preview_link AS preview_link19, 
  i1_.preview_type AS preview_type20, 
  i1_.is_active AS is_active21, 
  i1_.id AS id22, 
  i1_.name AS name23, 
  i1_.created_at AS created_at24, 
  i1_.updated_at AS updated_at25, 
  i1_.deleted_at AS deleted_at26, 
  i1_.goals AS goals27, 
  i1_.disclosure_statement AS disclosure_statement28, 
  i1_.embedded_video AS embedded_video29, 
  i1_.broadcast_chat_link AS broadcast_chat_link30, 
  i2_.atccode AS atccode31, 
  i2_.version AS version32, 
  i2_.description AS description33, 
  i2_.online_price AS online_price34, 
  i2_.mail_price AS mail_price35, 
  i2_.is_featured AS is_featured36, 
  i2_.code AS code37, 
  i2_.hours AS hours38, 
  i2_.summary AS summary39, 
  i2_.seo_keywords AS seo_keywords40, 
  i2_.seo_description AS seo_description41, 
  i2_.asha_code AS asha_code42, 
  i2_.preview_name AS preview_name43, 
  i2_.preview_link AS preview_link44, 
  i2_.preview_type AS preview_type45, 
  i2_.is_active AS is_active46, 
  i2_.id AS id47, 
  i2_.name AS name48, 
  i2_.created_at AS created_at49, 
  i2_.updated_at AS updated_at50, 
  i2_.deleted_at AS deleted_at51, 
  i0_.created_by AS created_by52, 
  i0_.updated_by AS updated_by53, 
  i1_.type AS type54, 
  i1_.item_format_id AS item_format_id55, 
  i1_.company_id AS company_id56, 
  i1_.created_by AS created_by57, 
  i1_.updated_by AS updated_by58, 
  i1_.format_video_id AS format_video_id59, 
  i1_.exam_id AS exam_id60, 
  i1_.survey_id AS survey_id61, 
  i1_.royalty_owner_id AS royalty_owner_id62, 
  i2_.type AS type63, 
  i2_.item_format_id AS item_format_id64, 
  i2_.company_id AS company_id65, 
  i2_.created_by AS created_by66, 
  i2_.updated_by AS updated_by67 
FROM 
  item_category i0_ 
  LEFT JOIN item_category_assignment i3_ ON i0_.id = i3_.item_category_id 
  LEFT JOIN item i1_ ON i1_.id = i3_.item_id 
  AND i1_.type IN ('Product') 
  AND (
    (
      i1_.deleted_at IS NULL 
      OR i1_.deleted_at > '2014-04-03 13:50:45'
    )
  ) 
  LEFT JOIN item_category_assignment i4_ ON i0_.id = i4_.item_category_id 
  LEFT JOIN item i2_ ON i2_.id = i4_.item_id 
  AND i2_.type IN ('Bundle') 
  AND (
    (
      i2_.deleted_at IS NULL 
      OR i2_.deleted_at > '2014-04-03 13:50:45'
    )
  ) 
WHERE 
  i0_.id IN (
    '108', 
    '175', 
    '100', 
    '202', 
    '198', 
    '203', 
    '199', 
    '200', 
    '201', 
    '197', 
    '101', 
    '98', 
    '102', 
    '131', 
    '105', 
    '41', 
    '72', 
    '64', 
    '73', 
    '194', 
    '195', 
    '29', 
    '189', 
    '139', 
    '103', 
    '37', 
    '99', 
    '14', 
    '110', 
    '193', 
    '80', 
    '111', 
    '68', 
    '183', 
    '39', 
    '71', 
    '53', 
    '66', 
    '178', 
    '179', 
    '180', 
    '176', 
    '174', 
    '75', 
    '17', 
    '32', 
    '81', 
    '181', 
    '182', 
    '74', 
    '104', 
    '184', 
    '26', 
    '49', 
    '190', 
    '191', 
    '36', 
    '24', 
    '85', 
    '30', 
    '107', 
    '91', 
    '90', 
    '185', 
    '23', 
    '196', 
    '60', 
    '89', 
    '21', 
    '95', 
    '65', 
    '28', 
    '33', 
    '58', 
    '187', 
    '9', 
    '132', 
    '12', 
    '43', 
    '192', 
    '5', 
    '62', 
    '40', 
    '87', 
    '7', 
    '83', 
    '27', 
    '6', 
    '86', 
    '10', 
    '13', 
    '15', 
    '70', 
    '69', 
    '121', 
    '67', 
    '93', 
    '97', 
    '92', 
    '94', 
    '188', 
    '177', 
    '82', 
    '96', 
    '42', 
    '137', 
    '19', 
    '11', 
    '63', 
    '20', 
    '51', 
    '57', 
    '8', 
    '22', 
    '48', 
    '35', 
    '4', 
    '135', 
    '61', 
    '186', 
    '106', 
    '109', 
    '88', 
    '16', 
    '31', 
    '34'
  ) 
ORDER BY 
  i0_.name ASC
Run Code Online (Sandbox Code Playgroud)

并解释它:

1   SIMPLE       i0_    ALL     PRIMARY                                                                       126   Using where; Using filesort  ,
1   SIMPLE       i3_    ref     item_category_id         item_category_id  4        cems-staging.i0_.id       6                                  ,
1   SIMPLE       i1_    eq_ref  PRIMARY                    PRIMARY           4        cems-staging.i3_.item_id  1     Using where                  ,
1   SIMPLE       i4_    ref     item_category_id         item_category_id  4        cems-staging.i0_.id       6                                  ,
1   SIMPLE       i2_    eq_ref  PRIMARY                    PRIMARY           4        cems-staging.i4_.item_id  1     Using where   
Run Code Online (Sandbox Code Playgroud)

*PHP*

这是Items模型的映射:

 /**
 * @var ArrayCollection
 * @ORM\ManyToMany(targetEntity="models\Category")
 * @ORM\JoinTable(name="item_category_assignment",
 *    joinColumns={@ORM\JoinColumn(name="item_id", referencedColumnName="id")},
 *    inverseJoinColumns={@ORM\JoinColumn(name="item_category_id", referencedColumnName="id")}
 * )
 */
protected $categories;
Run Code Online (Sandbox Code Playgroud)

和类别模型上的映射

    /**
 * @var ArrayCollection
 *
 * @ORM\ManyToMany(targetEntity="models\Course")
 * @ORM\JoinTable(name="item_category_assignment",
 *    inverseJoinColumns={@ORM\JoinColumn(name="item_id", referencedColumnName="id")},
 *    joinColumns={@ORM\JoinColumn(name="item_category_id", referencedColumnName="id")}
 * )
 */
protected $courses;

/**
 * @var ArrayCollection
 *
 * @ORM\ManyToMany(targetEntity="models\Bundle", mappedBy="categories", orphanRemoval=true)
 * @ORM\JoinTable(name="item_category_assignment",
 *    inverseJoinColumns={@ORM\JoinColumn(name="item_id", referencedColumnName="id")},
 *    joinColumns={@ORM\JoinColumn(name="item_category_id", referencedColumnName="id")}
 * )
 */
protected $bundles;

/**
 * @var ArrayCollection
 *
 * @ORM\ManyToMany(targetEntity="models\Package", mappedBy="categories", orphanRemoval=true)
 * @ORM\JoinTable(name="item_category_assignment",
 *    inverseJoinColumns={@ORM\JoinColumn(name="item_id", referencedColumnName="id")},
 *    joinColumns={@ORM\JoinColumn(name="item_category_id", referencedColumnName="id")}
 * )
 */
protected $packages;
Run Code Online (Sandbox Code Playgroud)

小智 1

对象和属性与行和列之间的区别在这里并不重要。

您正在尝试执行一系列LEFT JOINs 操作,而您可能应该使用UNIONs.

请参阅MicrosoftCROSS JOIN笛卡尔积的看法。他们确实总结得很好。

编辑:我认为这回答了“为什么我的第二次加入很慢?”的问题。

您是否想问:“请帮助我改进我的 3 模型 Doctrine 查询,使其运行时间少于 550 毫秒。” ?