可以在Clojure 1.4.0中扩展与defrecord一起使用吗？

Question

我试图使用'extend'在Clojure中使用map定义记录方法.以下适用于Clojure 1.4.0:

(defprotocol PointMethods
  (add [self other])
  (distance [self]))

(defrecord Point [x y]
  PointMethods
  (add [self other]
    (Point. (+ (:x self) (:x other)) (+ (:y self) (:y other))))
  (distance [self]
    (Math/sqrt (+ (* (:x self) (:x self)) (* (:y self) (:y self))))))

(def p1 (Point. 2 3))
(def p2 (Point. 1 1))

(def p3 (add p1 p2))
(println p3)
(println (distance p3))

但是这个版本失败了:

(defprotocol PointMethods
  (add [self other])
  (distance [self]))

(defrecord Point [x y])
(extend Point
  PointMethods
  {:add
   (fn [self other] (Point. (+ (:x self) (:x other)) (+ (:y self) (:y other))))
   :distance
   (fn [self] (Math/sqrt (+ (* (:x self) (:x self)) (* (:y self) (:y self)))))})

(def p1 (Point. 2 3))
(def p2 (Point. 1 1))

(def p3 (add p1 p2))
(println p3)
(println (distance p3))

Clojure Compiler: java.lang.IllegalArgumentException: No implementation of method: :add 
of protocol: #'user/PointMethods found for class: user.Point, compiling:(records.clj:16)]

第二个版本有什么问题？

Answer 1

正如其他人在对您的代码的评论中指出的那样，您编写的代码在 Clojure 1.4.0 中运行良好（我刚刚自己验证过）。您可能会遇到某种 IDE 配置错误，或者可能存在一些过时的缓存字节码。